top of page

Understanding the Denver Broncos' Management Challenges Since 2015: A Deep Dive into Issues, Failures, and Ways Forward

In the wake of their triumphant victory at Super Bowl 50, the Denver Broncos basked in the glory of their achievement, with fans and analysts alike anticipating a period of sustained success for the franchise. However, the optimism quickly dissipated as the team's trajectory took a sharp downward turn, marred by a succession of missteps and poor management decisions that have left the Broncos struggling to reclaim their former glory. This comprehensive analysis aims to meticulously dissect the multifaceted issues that have plagued the Broncos' management structure since 2015, meticulously examining the tumultuous landscape marked by coaching changes, quarterback struggles, questionable personnel moves, draft shortcomings, and the overarching absence of a cohesive organizational vision. Through an in-depth examination of these factors, this analysis seeks to provide insights into the root causes of the Broncos' decline and offer potential pathways for the franchise to navigate towards a brighter future on the gridiron.

Coaching Carousel

The post-2015 era for the Broncos has been characterized by a lack of coaching stability, with the team cycling through multiple head coaches in search of the right leadership. Following the departure of Gary Kubiak, the team embarked on a search for his successor, ultimately settling on Vance Joseph in 2017. However, Joseph's tenure was characterized by inconsistency and failed to yield the desired results. Subsequent hires, including Vic Fangio in 2019, brought flashes of promise but ultimately fell short of expectations. The constant turnover in coaching staffs has disrupted player development, hindered team cohesion, and contributed to the Broncos' struggles in establishing a consistent identity and game plan.

Quarterback Quandary

Central to the Broncos' post-2015 woes has been their persistent struggle to secure a franchise quarterback following the retirement of Peyton Manning. Despite significant investments in free agent quarterbacks such as Case Keenum and Joe Flacco, the team has been unable to find a long-term solution under center.

Draft selections like Paxton Lynch and Trevor Siemian have also failed to provide stability at the position, perpetuating a cycle of uncertainty and instability. The lack of a reliable signal-caller has hampered offensive productivity, hindered team chemistry, and contributed to the Broncos' inability to compete at the highest level.

Personnel Problems

The Broncos' management has encountered numerous challenges in personnel management since 2015, particularly in free agency. High-profile acquisitions such as Ja'Wuan James and Melvin Gordon have failed to meet expectations, either due to injury concerns or underperformance on the field.

Additionally, the departure of key defensive stalwarts like Aqib Talib and Malik Jackson created significant voids that were not adequately addressed through subsequent acquisitions or draft selections. These personnel deficiencies have weakened the team's overall depth, undermined their defensive prowess, and contributed to their struggles in remaining competitive within the NFL landscape.

While the Broncos have experienced intermittent success in the draft post-2015, highlighted by standout selections like Bradley Chubb and Courtland Sutton, there have also been notable misses and underwhelming picks. Draft busts such as Paxton Lynch and Garett Bolles underscore the team's challenges in consistently identifying and developing talent through the draft process. These draft deficiencies have hindered the Broncos' ability to build a sustainable foundation for success, leading to gaps in their roster and limitations in their overall competitiveness.

Lack of Vision

At the core of the Broncos' post-2015 management crisis lies a fundamental lack of cohesive organizational vision and direction. The team has struggled to establish a clear identity and long-term plan for success, resulting in inconsistency and uncertainty in decision-making across various facets of the organization. Changes in coaching staffs, quarterback strategies, personnel decisions, and draft approaches have all reflected a lack of cohesive vision from top management. Without a defined roadmap for success, the Broncos have floundered in their attempts to maintain competitiveness within the ever-evolving landscape of the NFL.

Despite the formidable challenges they face, there remains optimism for the Broncos to chart a path to redemption and reclaim their status as a perennial contender. With the recent appointment of George Paton as general manager in 2021, there exists an opportunity for a comprehensive restructuring and revitalization of the team's management structure. However, this endeavor will necessitate a holistic overhaul of management strategies, encompassing smarter coaching decisions, shrewder quarterback acquisitions, more astute personnel moves, and a refined draft approach. The Broncos must prioritize stability, consistency, and a clear long-term vision to forge a sustainable path forward and reestablish themselves as a preeminent force within the NFL.

In recent years, the Denver Broncos organization has faced significant challenges and undergone notable changes, leading to a period of uncertainty and instability. One key move was the acquisition of Sean Payton, a highly regarded coach, in a trade deal that involved relinquishing valuable assets. This trade saw the departure of three players – quarterback Drew Lock, tight end Noah Fant, and defensive tackle Shelby Harris – along with a significant number of draft picks, including two first-round picks, two second-round picks, and a fifth-round pick, to secure the services of Payton. However, despite the initial excitement surrounding this acquisition, Payton's tenure with the Broncos proved short-lived, as he was released after just two seasons, highlighting the organization's struggle to find stability at the coaching position.

Furthermore, the decision to release Justin Simmons, a talented and key player in the Broncos' defense, added to the turmoil within the organization. Simmons' departure signaled a shift in the team's roster and raised questions about the team's long-term strategy and direction. Additionally, the hiring of Nathaniel Hackett as head coach a few years prior represented another significant change for the Broncos. Hackett's appointment was met with both optimism and skepticism, as fans and analysts speculated about his ability to lead the team to success amidst the ongoing challenges facing the organization. Overall, the Denver Broncos organization has experienced a period of uncertainty and instability characterized by significant roster changes, coaching transitions, and strategic decisions that have yet to yield desired results on the field. As the team navigates through these challenges, the future remains uncertain, with fans and stakeholders hoping for a return to prominence in the highly competitive landscape of professional football.

Ultimately, the Denver Broncos' post-2015 management crisis represents a complex confluence of challenges, shortcomings, and missed opportunities across coaching, quarterbacking, personnel management, draft strategies, and organizational vision. The lack of stability, coherence, and foresight within the team's management structure has contributed to a tangible decline in their on-field performance and overall competitiveness. Moving forward, the Broncos must confront these issues head-on, implement strategic changes, and commit to building a cohesive and competitive team capable of navigating the complexities of the modern NFL landscape. Only through decisive action, steadfast commitment, and a renewed sense of purpose can the Broncos aspire to reclaim their position among the league's elite franchises.

14 views0 comments


bottom of page